Employee Value Proposition Framework Part III: Who Will I Do It With?

In Part I of this series, we considered what an employer gives its people. In Part II we looked at what people get to do and become.
Now we come to the people they do it with. Colleagues, managers, leaders. customers, service-users. The people you work alongside, learn from, depend on and, occasionally, disagree with.
I need to tread a careful line here. This isn't about organisational culture or personality. That's the subject of the next article. Right now, I want to concentrate on the people themselves: who they are, what they bring and how they're brought together - and you you bring them into the employee value proposition framework.
Of course, these things aren't independent. Who people are influences what they do, and how they do it. That influences the experience of work, which in turn shapes your culture.
And that's precisely why we need to explore these questions when developing an employee value proposition.
I believe in the interconnectedness of all things. We're looking for the connections. How one feature of your organisation creates something valuable somewhere else. How the combination of people, skills and responsibilities produces an experience that might not be available with another employer.
That's where you start finding something distinctive. Something that gives people a reason to choose you.
Colleagues: Who Will I Actually Work With?
Let's start with colleagues. The people doing the work. What are they like?
And please, please don't say "we're like a family". It's trite, it's clichéd and it's not particularly helpful. Ask someone about their most dysfunctional relationships, and there's a reasonable chance their family will feature somewhere. We can do better than that.
Are your colleagues particularly experienced? Are they experts in their fields? Or do you have a broad mix of people, bringing different skills and perspectives? Perhaps you've got people with decades of knowledge working alongside those who are relatively new to the profession. Or pockets of deep expertise in different parts of the organisation.
How are those people brought together? Are they organised around professions, products, customers or projects? What does that arrangement enable them to achieve?
And what might it mean for someone joining you? There is a difference between joining an organisation where you're surrounded by people who know far more than you, and one where you're expected to be the expert from day one. Both might be attractive, but not to the same person.
It's also worth asking why your workforce looks the way it does. Perhaps you've built expertise over many years. Perhaps you've deliberately recruited people from other industries. Or perhaps your business model depends on bringing together specialisms that don't usually work alongside one another. Behind those choices are stories about your organisation that could become part of your employer value proposition.
Managers: Who Will I Be Working For?
Managers deserve particular attention because, for many employees, their manager is one of the most important people in their working life.
We're all familiar with the idea of the accidental manager. Someone who never set out to manage people, but found that it came with the next promotion, a little more responsibility and a little more money. So, how are managers selected? Do people become managers because they're excellent at their professional specialism, or because they have the aptitude to lead and support others?
We touched on career progression in Part II. There's a connection here. Can people become more senior without taking on line-management responsibilities? If they can, is that route considered as valuable as becoming a manager? And once people become managers, what happens? What training, mentoring or support do they receive? How much time are they expected to devote to managing people, rather than doing their own work? I think that last question is particularly important. It's one thing to train managers. It's another to give them the time to apply what they've learned.
For someone considering joining your organisation, these aren't abstract questions. They help them understand the sort of management they can expect and how much support they might receive.
A Sidebar: How Honest Does Your Employee Value Proposition Framework Need to Be?
This brings us to an interesting dilemma. There are plenty of organisations that don't do particularly well by their managers. They don't give them the skills, the support or the time they need. Sometimes, they treat the extra responsibility and remuneration as permission to keep piling on more work.
I'm all for authenticity in an EVP. But does that mean you have to tell everyone about everything you don't do particularly well?
No. Your EVP isn't an audit report. You're looking for the most attractive, distinctive and realistic reasons to work for your organisation. You don't have to put every weakness on the front page.
But there's an important difference between choosing what to emphasise and making claims you can't support.
If the experience of being a manager is poor, and that's affecting performance, engagement or retention, you have an issue. Particularly if that experience is already visible through employee reviews or word of mouth. Ideally, the organisation should address the problem. That's not always something the person responsible for employer branding can control.
What you can control is how you respond. Don't make grand promises about a wonderful management experience that your employees wouldn't recognise. Instead, look at what you can prove. What has changed? What support has been introduced? Is there evidence that things are improving? And if there's no evidence, perhaps management isn't one of the things you should build your EVP around. At least, not yet.
Authenticity doesn't require you to say everything. But realism does require you to stand behind what you say.
Leadership: Who Is Running This Organisation?
What can you say about your leaders? Perhaps they're the founders, with a great origin story. Perhaps your CEO started in the stockroom at 16 and worked their way to the top.
Or perhaps there's no great story of entrepreneurial ambition or personal triumph. You've assembled a capable group of people from your own talent and from other organisations. That's interesting too. What experience do they bring? What have they achieved? Why have they chosen to work here? And what do people know about them?
They may be visible in your industry, in the local community or in the media. They might have strong views about the future of your sector, or particular passions that influence the direction of the organisation. How accessible are they to the people they lead? Do employees hear directly from them? Are there opportunities to understand their thinking, ask questions or challenge their decisions?
They may never be Steve Jobs. They'll probably never have a quote shared on LinkedIn alongside a moody black-and-white headshot. That doesn't mean they're not interesting. Or even inspirational.
Leaders represent your organisation, internally and externally. What people know about them can make a significant difference to whether they want to work for them. And remember, this doesn't have to be a story about one charismatic individual. The collective experience and capability of a leadership team might be far more compelling.
Working Relationships: How Are People Brought Together?
We've considered the individuals. Now let's consider the connections between them. People in different teams, sometimes even within the same team, will have different responsibilities and priorities. What makes those priorities complementary rather than competing?
How are teams structured? Who works with whom? Where do different specialisms come together? Are there opportunities for people to work beyond their immediate team?
These questions might reveal something interesting about how your organisation operates. Perhaps people work in small, multidisciplinary teams, bringing together skills that would be separated in most other organisations. Perhaps employees have access to experts they would rarely encounter elsewhere. Or perhaps the scale of your organisation means people can work directly with senior decision-makers rather than through several layers of management.
Those are tangible differences to the employee experience. They might offer quicker learning, greater access to expertise or more opportunity to contribute. And there's something else worth considering. In my research into Joy at Work, I asked 300 people in a nationally representative UK survey which interactions were most likely to bring them joy at work.
51% selected interactions with their direct colleagues as one of their top two choices. Another 32% selected interactions with their peer group. The people around us aren't simply a means of getting the work done. They can be a significant part of what makes the work enjoyable.
So, what relationships does your organisation make possible? And what might someone gain from being part of them?
Customers and Service Users: Who Else Will I Work With?
There's another group we shouldn't overlook. The people outside the organisation with whom employees interact. Customers, clients, patients, learners, service users, suppliers or partners. Depending on the job, these people may be among the most important relationships someone has at work.
In the same Joy at Work research, 31% selected interactions with service users as one of the two interactions most likely to bring them joy. For paying customers, the figure was 20%. It's worth considering what kind of relationships your organisation allows people to build.
Do employees get to know customers over many years? Do they work directly with the people who benefit from their expertise? Do they get to see what happens as a result of their work? These can be important differences between otherwise similar employers. And they may be especially valuable when you're trying to attract people from other industries, who might have quite different expectations of the people they'll encounter.
Inclusion and Belonging: Who Gets to Be Part of This?
Now we're getting very close to organisational culture. How do people feel that they belong? How are different backgrounds, experiences and perspectives welcomed and valued?
I'll come back to the cultural side of this in Part IV. For now, I want to concentrate on what you can demonstrate about the people who make up your organisation and the opportunities available to them. Who joins? Who stays? Who progresses? Who is represented in different roles and levels of seniority? What have you done to make it possible for different kinds of people to participate and succeed?
Perhaps you've made changes to recruitment, onboarding, accessibility or career development. Perhaps you've introduced policies that have opened up opportunities for people who previously found them difficult to access.
If you've got great initiatives, tell us about them. But please don't stop at the policies and good intentions. What difference have they actually made? Have more people from under-represented groups joined or progressed? Are people staying longer? Are teams drawing on a wider range of experience? And what has that enabled your organisation to achieve?
I'm particularly interested in examples that go beyond something being subjectively "nice" or "good". Perhaps greater diversity of experience has helped you understand customers better. Perhaps improved accessibility has enabled you to recruit specialists you would previously have missed. Or perhaps you've improved retention. If so, let's put some numbers on that. Who is staying longer? How much longer? And, most importantly, why?
There's an important distinction here between saying that everyone is welcome and demonstrating that different kinds of people can actually succeed. For your EVP, the second is considerably more valuable.
How Do People Become Part of a Distinctive EVP?
As with the first two articles, I'm not suggesting that you need a pillar for colleagues, another for management, another for leadership and another for inclusion. That would take us straight back to the long list of features that I'm trying to help you avoid. Instead, we're looking for the connections.
Perhaps your organisation brings together unusually deep expertise, but operates in small teams. That means people can learn directly from specialists, develop more quickly and take on responsibilities they might have to wait years for elsewhere. That's a potentially compelling story. And it connects to the development and progression themes we explored in Part II.
Or perhaps people work directly with customers whose lives they can make a measurable difference to. That's a connection between the people you work with and the satisfaction you gain from the work itself.
Neither story needs to appeal to everyone. It needs to appeal to the people you most want to attract and retain.
The challenge when developing your employee value proposition is to identify which of those differences matter, and how they help explain why someone should choose you.
That brings us to Part IV.
Because although I've tried to concentrate here on who people are, there's a closely connected question about how they behave, individually and collectively.
And that takes us into organisational culture. A subject that can feel even more difficult to pin down, but which I think can be just as tangible, distinctive and important to your EVP.
Sam Monteath is the founder of Reason Why: The UK's first dedicated, research-led employer branding agency providing research-led employer branding that gives people reasons to choose you
Discover more about the types of research I conduct here
Discover more about who I work with here



Comments