top of page

Employee Value Proposition Framework Part IV: What Kind of Organisation Am I Joining?

3 hours ago
7 min read

In Part I, we looked at "What do I get?" In Part II, "What do I get to do and become?" And in Part III, "Who will I do it with?"


These are nuanced questions. Finding the answers can be tricky. Finding the connections between them, and turning them into a narrative that is uniquely and powerfully you, is tricky too. But at least we're dealing with things that are relatively tangible. Things we can describe, measure and prove.


Now we're getting into organisational culture. And that's a different challenge.

Culture is something people in an organisation may feel strongly. They may recognise it instantly when they experience it, without necessarily being able to put it into words.

Your culture may be well documented. You might have a set of values, defined behaviours and a shared understanding of what they mean in practice. I'd suggest those organisations are the exception rather than the rule.


So, when developing your employee value proposition, there's a good chance you'll need to find a way to describe the culture yourself.


Why? Because people want to know.

"What's the culture like?" is one of the most natural questions a candidate can ask. In an interview, at a careers fair, or just in conversation with someone who already works there.

There's a reason employer branding tries so hard to bring culture to life. The question is how to do that credibly, without getting drawn into a much bigger exercise than you intended.


Do You Need to Define Your Organisational Culture?

I'd argue that you probably don't. At least, not for the purpose of creating your EVP.


Defining organisational culture is a pretty specialised task in its own right. And if you're going to do it properly, you'll need to ask some difficult questions.


Difficult questions require preparation, stakeholder support and a willingness to act on what you discover. You need to be able to reassure people that their honesty won't be wasted, or worse, held against them.


That may not be a path you want to go down when you're simply trying to define or refine your employer value proposition.


So, what's the alternative? In keeping with everything I've said in this series, work as far as possible with what already exists.


It's faster. The research may already have been done, the findings considered and the conclusions accepted. So, you're less likely to get bogged down in approvals. That's where so many EVPs stall.


If you're going to produce an entirely new description of your culture and present it publicly, people – important people – will want their say. They'll want to consider the language, test the claims, suggest alternatives and perhaps question whether it's really how the organisation works. All perfectly reasonable. But it takes time.


And the more people who need to agree, the greater the temptation to compromise the language until everyone is comfortable. Which is often when you lose the very things that made it distinctive.


Working with what's already understood and accepted won't remove every approval. But it reduces the amount of new territory to negotiate.


And, existing evidence gives you something to build your claims around. That's increasingly important. Candidates now use AI to bring together all kinds of information about an employer, rather than relying on the promises on its careers site.


If your EVP is supported by evidence that people can discover elsewhere, you're in a much stronger position than if you're simply making claims.


Start With What Employees Have Already Told You

I'd begin with what you already know about your workforce and how people feel about working there. However you've listened, and whatever the original purpose, there's a good chance you'll have collected intelligence about the employee experience.


The obvious place is an employee engagement survey. Even if it doesn't explicitly ask about culture, it will probably tell you something about how the organisation operates.

  • Are leaders genuinely accessible to everyone?

  • Are people equipped and encouraged to speak up?

  • Is employee wellbeing seen as something that matters to the organisation?

  • Are people trusted to make decisions?

Individually, these might be themes in their own right. Together, they start to build a picture of what's prioritised, how decisions are made and what people can expect.


Qualitative research can be even more revealing. Interview and focus group findings, exit interviews, onboarding feedback. There's potentially a lot to work with. The trick is to look beyond the scores and the individual comments.

What do the findings, taken together, tell you about how things work around here?

And importantly, how consistent is that picture. You're looking for patterns that help explain the culture, rather than isolated opinions that happen to support the story you'd like to tell.


What Can Employee Reviews Tell You About Your Culture?

Then there's the external version of employee listening. Glassdoor, Indeed and the other employer review sites. There are all kinds of issues with these. Who chooses to leave a review? What motivates them? How representative are their experiences? How recent are they?


So don't treat them as a definitive description of your organisation. But, they're part of the information candidates will discover about you. That makes them an important part of your employer reputation, whether you like what they say or not.


Look for recurring themes, particularly where they align with what your own employee listening has uncovered. If people consistently talk about supportive colleagues, genuine independence or close relationships with senior leaders, that’s worth exploring.


You may also find uncomfortable contradictions. If you believe you have an open, collaborative culture, while employees repeatedly describe something quite different, you've got a problem.

And, as I said in Part III, the answer isn't necessarily to tell everyone every weakness. But you do need to make claims you can stand behind.


Company Values: Getting Beyond the Vanilla

Then there are your organisational values and behaviours.

Values can be hard to work with. There are many vanilla, say-nothing statements:

  • Integrity

  • Trust

  • Clarity


Let's apply the Law of the Ridiculous Reverse: “If the opposite of a statement is plainly absurd, the original statement probably wasn't worth making in the first place”. No organisation is going to publish the values:

  • Dishonour

  • Deceit

  • Obscurity


But that doesn't mean those values aren't useful. They may have a very specific, widely understood meaning within the organisation. Take integrity. Perhaps, in your organisation, integrity means proactively telling customers when you've made a mistake. Not finding a way to avoid responsibility. Accepting a short-term cost to protect a longer-term relationship.


That's a particular interpretation of integrity, with real consequences for how people do their jobs. You've moved beyond a bland statement of something everyone claims to believe, towards a specific description of your organisation. That's potentially distinctive.


Behaviours: What Happens When There's a Difficult Choice?


If your organisation has defined behaviours alongside its values, they may tell you even more. What does the organisation want people to do? What does it actively discourage?

I'm often particularly interested in the negative indicators. The things people are told not to do. Because they can tell you a lot about the tensions within an organisation.


It's easy to say that you value quality, speed, collaboration, accountability and customer service. But what happens when you have to choose between two desirable outcomes, which one takes priority? And why?

That's where you start to understand something meaningful about culture.


Researching Culture: Explore the Tensions


A lot of my research explores tensions between two positive options.

Rather than asking someone to describe the culture, I'll give them two different ways of working and ask which better represents their organisation. Once they've placed themselves somewhere on the spectrum between the two, they're usually able to explain their choice in considerable detail.


Take accuracy versus speed. Do you want something done right, or done quickly? Of course, everyone wants both. But at some point, something has to give.


Think about a Formula 1 pit crew. They're trying to be exceptionally quick, but accuracy has to take priority. It doesn't matter how quickly you change a tyre if it falls off at the first corner.

So, how does that tension work in your organisation? Are people encouraged to take the time to get everything right, even when that means missing a deadline? Or is there an expectation that you'll make a decision with the information available, get something out and improve it later?

Neither is inherently better. But the choices your organisation consistently makes tell people something about what working there will be like.


Turning Organisational Culture Into a Distinctive EVP

We've taken an idea that can feel difficult to define and found several ways to make it more tangible. We've looked at what employees already tell us. What they say externally. What the organisation claims to value. And what actually happens when people face difficult choices.


Together, those things can give you a much richer picture of the organisation's personality. And, perhaps more importantly, what that personality means for someone considering working there.

Not a grand new cultural definition – just the aspects of your culture that are relevant, distinctive and credible enough to form part of your EVP.


There may be several of them. But, as with the other questions in this series, that doesn't mean they all need to make it into your final proposition. Look for the ones that connect with the other things you've discovered.


Perhaps you're an organisation that gives people considerable independence, values quick decisions and accepts that mistakes are an inevitable part of making progress. That connects culture to autonomy, learning and achievement.


That enables someone to see themselves thriving in your organisation, precisely because they recognise and value the way you do things. And when someone else can see that it probably isn't for them. That's EVP doing its job.


Next time we're getting into another big question: What are we trying to achieve?

Purpose and direction. What the organisation exists to do, where it's going, and what part employees get to play in making that happen.


Sam Monteath is the founder of Reason Why: The UK's first dedicated, research-led employer branding agency providing research-led employer branding that gives people reasons to choose you


Discover more about the types of research I conduct here


Discover more about who I work with here


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Research-led strategy to define or refine employer value proposition.
Enhancing recruitment, employee experience and internal communications

bottom of page